An administrative law judge considers evidence from DPS and the driver or the driver’s attorney. The judge then decides whether DPS proved each issue required for the particular type of administrative action.
The hearing does not determine guilt or innocence in the criminal DWI case.
Who Conducts the ALR Hearing?
ALR hearings are conducted by an administrative law judge through the State Office of Administrative Hearings. Texas law provides for a record of the proceeding.
The hearing location and format depend on the applicable statute, county and arrangements made by the parties. Texas law permits certain hearings to be conducted by telephone conference when the driver and DPS consent.
The hearing is more formal than an ordinary DPS customer-service appointment. Evidence, testimony, objections and legal standards can affect the result.
What Happens Before the Hearing?
After a timely request, DPS sends a notice containing the hearing information. Before the hearing, the driver or attorney may seek and examine available evidence.
Materials may include:
- DIC-24 statutory warning.
- DIC-25 suspension notice.
- Officer’s sworn report.
- Arrest and incident reports.
- Dash-camera or body-camera recordings.
- Breath-test records.
- Blood-test reports and laboratory records.
- Documents concerning the traffic stop and arrest.
- Records concerning the requested specimen and alleged refusal.
- Driving record and license information relevant to the administrative action.
Not every item exists in every case. Procedures for obtaining evidence, issuing a subpoena or securing witness testimony may involve legal requirements and deadlines.
Who Has the Burden of Proof?
DPS bears the burden of establishing the required administrative issues by a preponderance of the evidence. This is a civil standard and is lower than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard used in a criminal DWI prosecution.
DPS must still prove every issue required for the specific suspension. The judge should not sustain the administrative action if a required issue is not established.
Issues in a Breath- or Blood-Test Failure Hearing
Texas Transportation Code Section 524.035 identifies the principal issues in a test-failure case. DPS generally must prove:
- That the person had an alcohol concentration at or above the applicable statutory level while operating a motor vehicle in a public place, or that the applicable under-21 standard was met.
- That reasonable suspicion existed for the stop or probable cause existed for the arrest.
Evidence can raise questions concerning:
- The factual basis for the traffic stop.
- The relationship between the reported concentration and the time of driving.
- Whether the test and specimen are connected to the correct person and event.
- Whether the records offered by DPS establish the necessary elements.
- Whether video or witness testimony conflicts with written reports.
The administrative hearing is not a complete criminal trial. Its issues are limited to those established by the applicable ALR statute.
Issues in an Alleged Test-Refusal Hearing
Texas Transportation Code Section 724.042 generally requires DPS to establish:
- Reasonable suspicion or probable cause to stop or arrest the person.
- Probable cause to believe the person operated a motor vehicle in a public place while intoxicated.
- That the person was placed under arrest and asked to submit to the taking of a specimen.
- That the person refused the requested specimen.
A refusal case can involve questions about the request, the statutory warning, the driver’s response and the circumstances under which the interaction occurred.
A later warrant-authorized blood draw does not necessarily erase an earlier alleged refusal. The administrative and criminal consequences must be analyzed separately.
What Happens During the Hearing?
The precise sequence can vary, but an ALR hearing commonly includes:
- The case is called before the administrative law judge.
- DPS presents documents, testimony or other evidence supporting the suspension.
- The driver or attorney may object to evidence when a legal basis exists.
- Witnesses may be questioned and cross-examined when testimony is presented.
- The driver may present relevant evidence and legal arguments.
- The judge determines whether DPS proved every required issue.
An attorney may use the hearing to examine the administrative case and question a witness, but the availability of testimony and evidence depends on the procedural steps taken before the hearing.
Does the Arresting Officer Attend?
An officer does not automatically appear in every ALR hearing. Attendance can depend on whether a valid subpoena was requested and served, whether testimony is required and the procedural posture of the case.
Do not assume that requesting a hearing automatically requires the officer to attend. Subpoena rules and deadlines should be addressed well before the scheduled hearing.
Possible Hearing Decisions
DPS does not prove every required issue
The administrative law judge should decline to sustain the proposed ALR suspension. DPS must reinstate the license or rescind the applicable denial as provided by the governing statute. This result does not automatically dismiss the related DWI charge.
DPS proves the required issues
The judge may sustain the suspension or disqualification. The applicable period depends on the type of case, testing allegation, license and prior administrative history. The driver may need to evaluate an appeal, occupational driver’s license or reinstatement requirements.
Can an ALR Decision Be Appealed?
Texas law allows certain ALR decisions to be appealed. An appeal has separate filing requirements and a short deadline. A person considering an appeal should review the signed decision and obtain legal advice immediately.
Do not assume that filing an appeal automatically authorizes driving. The effect of an appeal and any stay must be evaluated under the applicable law and order.
Can Someone Obtain an Occupational Driver’s License?
Some people with an ALR suspension may qualify to seek an occupational driver’s license for essential needs such as work, school or necessary household responsibilities.
Eligibility and conditions depend on the person’s license history, type of suspension, court order, insurance documentation and other requirements. An occupational license is not automatic and may contain geographic, purpose, time, ignition-interlock or reporting restrictions.
ALR Hearing Questions
How long does an ALR hearing take?
There is no single duration. The time depends on the evidence, witnesses, objections, contested issues and the judge’s schedule.
Will I have to testify?
Not necessarily. Whether testimony is advisable is a case-specific legal decision because statements can affect the administrative and criminal matters.
Can the hearing help the DWI defense?
The hearing may provide an opportunity to examine reports, evidence or testimony connected with the arrest. However, its primary purpose is deciding the administrative license action.
Does a dismissed DWI automatically erase the ALR suspension?
The proceedings are separate. Texas law provides consequences for certain qualifying acquittals, but a dismissal, reduction or other criminal disposition should be evaluated under the specific statutes and DPS procedures rather than assumed to control the administrative record.
What if I live outside Austin?
ALR rules apply statewide. Location and hearing arrangements depend on the county of arrest, applicable statute and instructions issued for the hearing.
Can you win an ALR hearing?
Yes. If DPS does not prove every required issue, the administrative law judge should not sustain the suspension. Results depend on the evidence, the procedural steps taken before the hearing and the facts of the stop, arrest and testing decision.
What happens if I do not attend my ALR hearing?
Texas DPS states that failing to appear for the hearing results in an affirmative finding and the decision becomes final. If you cannot attend, address the scheduling problem before the hearing date.
What should I bring to an ALR hearing?
Bring the hearing notice, your DIC-25 or Notice of Suspension, proof of your hearing request, your driver license and any documents you or your attorney plan to offer. Follow any filing instructions in the notice from DPS or the State Office of Administrative Hearings.
Continue Reading
- Return to the Austin ALR Hearing GuideOverview of the ALR process and how it differs from the DWI case
- Review the 15-day deadline and request processWhen the deadline starts and how to submit through DPS
Recommended Austin ALR and DWI counsel
Need Help With an Austin ALR Hearing?
If you want legal representation for an ALR matter arising from an Austin or Travis County DWI arrest, consider contacting The Hull Firm. Its attorneys represent clients in administrative license proceedings and related criminal DWI cases.
Every case is different. No attorney can guarantee the outcome of an ALR hearing or criminal case.
Discuss Your Austin ALR Case With The Hull FirmDisclosure: This website’s publisher has a business relationship with The Hull Firm.